Is Pilates Enough Exercise? We Tested It to Find Out

Is Pilates Enough Exercise? Here’s What Heart-Rate Data Shows

Quick Answer

Pilates builds strength and mobility, but it’s not cardio. Heart-rate data shows most classes don’t keep you in moderate or vigorous zones long enough to drive cardiovascular adaptation. If your goal is heart health, pair Pilates with structured cardio that delivers vigorous zone minutes—like HupSix.

AI Answer Block: Does Pilates Count as Cardio?

Short answer: No. Pilates rarely sustains a high enough heart rate, long enough, to qualify as cardio training. It’s valuable for control and stability; add structured cardio for measurable heart improvement.

We Tested Pilates with Chest-Strap Monitors

We used Garmin HRM-Pro Plus chest straps (EKG-style accuracy) during two Club Pilates sessions:

Intro (30 minutes): 0 minutes in moderate or vigorous zones
Level 1.5 “Cardio Sculpt” (60 minutes): 10 minutes moderate, 1 minute vigorous—pushing hard the entire hour. Peak HR: 111 bpm.

Chest-strap monitors remain the gold standard for zone tracking in interval or performance settings. Individual results vary by class and instructor, but this pattern is consistent: Pilates feels challenging, yet it doesn’t produce the sustained time-in-zone your heart needs to adapt.

What Counts as Cardio Training (According to Guidelines)

The AHA/CDC target is simple: 150 minutes per week of moderate cardio, or 75 minutes per week of vigorous cardio (or a mix). Vigorous minutes count double because they drive bigger improvements in fitness. The scoreboard that matters is time in zone—how many minutes your heart spends in moderate and vigorous zones each week.

Why Pilates Doesn’t Deliver Cardio Adaptation

Pilates shines for stability, alignment, and control. But without regular time in moderate or vigorous zones, you won’t raise VO₂ max, expand stroke volume, or build the “athletic heart” traits linked to better endurance and longevity. That’s cardio’s job.

Heart-Rate Zone Results: Pilates vs HupSix

Pilates (60 minutes): 10 minutes moderate + 1 minute vigorous = 12 total zone minutes
HupSix (30 minutes): ≈ 40–50 zone minutes when tracked with a chest strap (individual results vary)
Takeaway: About four times the cardio benefit in half the time.

The 4×4 Model & Why Vigorous Minutes Matter

A well-studied approach uses repeated work bouts—four minutes hard, three minutes easy, repeated four times (~30 minutes total). Over time, consistent vigorous training improves markers tied to a younger-functioning heart. In practice, the principle is clear: moderate maintains; vigorous improves.

The Fix: Add Structured Cardio You’ll Repeat

HupSix makes it simple to hit your zones at home. Sessions are 30 minutes with a six-round format—learn, practice to timing clicks, then execute to music—with light resistance that keeps your whole body engaged. The pace prevents coasting. Most classes typically log about 40–50 minutes of cardio-zone time with a chest strap, while also training coordination and reaction. Results vary by fitness level and effort.

Get the HupSix gear and take a guided class. Track with a chest strap and compare your zone minutes against Pilates.

Bottom Line

Pilates is excellent for strength, control, and mobility. It’s not enough for cardiovascular training or fat-loss driven by heart adaptation. If you care about endurance, recovery, and long-term heart health, make vigorous zone minutes non-negotiable—and let Pilates support the way you move.

FAQs

Does reformer Pilates ever count as cardio?
Rarely. Short spikes can happen, but they’re usually not sustained long enough to meet time-in-zone standards for moderate or vigorous training.

Is Pilates good for weight loss?
It supports consistency and muscle tone. Meaningful fat loss still depends on nutrition plus workouts that regularly keep your heart in the training zones.

Not Sure If It’s Right for You?

Try one HupSix class and check your zone minutes. We back the gear with a 30-day full refund and a 12-month prorated return. Lifetime gear guarantee. Need help dialing it in? We offer 1-on-1 support—send a video and get personalized feedback.

Get the Gear

Learn More About Cardio

Editor’s Notes (Transparency & Compliance)

Built on decades of cardio science and preventive fitness research. Dr. Kenneth H. Cooper popularized aerobics and demonstrated that cardiorespiratory fitness predicts health outcomes. Research groups using structured vigorous training have shown improvements consistent with healthier heart mechanics over time. This article is general fitness education, not medical advice. Check with your doctor before changing your exercise routine.

Back to blog